Agency Appointments

The Brethren Mutual Insurance Company is committed to the independent agency system and relies on its independent insurance agency force as its primary distribution method. The Company is currently represented by over 250 independent insurance agencies located in Maryland, Pennsylvania and Virginia.

Brethren Mutual is currently appointing new agencies in Pennsylvania and Virginia. Here are just some of the reasons why you may want to consider representing Brethren Mutual:

  • Full line of competitively priced property/casualty products.
  • Competitive commission level.
  • Quality customer service.
  • Quick claims handling.
  • Contingency bonus advantages.
  • Automated services and rating software.
  • Professional staff of 150 employees.

If you are an independent agency located in Maryland, Pennsylvania or Virginia and are interested in finding out if your agency meets Brethren Mutual's appointment criteria, please contact the respective marketing manager listed below.

PA Marketing Manager
Frank Sombers
800-621-4264 (ext. 1320)
fax: 717-738-2577

PA Marketing Manager
Larry Kiser
800-621-4264 (ext. 1395)

VA Marketing Manager
Ken Jarvis
800-621-4264 (ext. 1331)

VA Marketing Manager
Melisa Davis-Harris
800-621-4264 (ext. 1302)

MD Marketing Manager
Don Bassett
800-621-4264 (ext. 1326)
fax: 240-313-3858

Contact Us

Brethren Mutual's Policyholder
Services Department

(800) 621-4264
Email: Policyholder Services

Mailing Address
149 North Edgewood Drive
Hagerstown, MD  21740
Driving Directions
Office Hours