About Us

Established in 1897, The Brethren Mutual Insurance Company is owned by its policyholders, rather than stockholders. We are a true "mutually owned" company. Brethren Mutual is a property/casualty insurance carrier with a stable foundation. Although we currently have no affiliation with the Church of the Brethren, our founding fathers were Brethren churchmen who agreed to band together to insure one another's homes and farms against the perils of fire and lightning.

Brethren Mutual is extremely proud of its heritage, as well as, its niche in the insurance marketplace. We have grown from a small insurance organization that protected local farm dwellings, crops and personal belongings, to a regional company currently servicing the personal, business and farm insurance needs of policyholders in Maryland, Pennsylvania, Virginia, and Delaware as well as the commercial needs of policyholders in the District of Columbia.

Brethren Mutual is committed to providing value, quality in insurance protection, reliable service and financial integrity. At every level, Brethren Mutual employees share a genuine concern for the satisfaction and well-being of policyholders and agents. Our staff of 143 professionals works closely as a team from one central office in Hagerstown, Maryland to give each customer the personal attention they deserve.

For more information about Brethren Mutual, click here to download a copy of our Company brochure.

Contact Us

Brethren Mutual's Policyholder
Services Department

(800) 621-4264
Email: Policyholder Services

Mailing Address
149 North Edgewood Drive
Hagerstown, MD  21740
Driving Directions
Office Hours